The first time a work of art I created garnered any praise, from someone other than my parents, was when I was in the first grade. The challenge Miss Ryon threw down to the class was to draw a garden from the eyes of a bug. Way before A Bug’s Life or Antz, in my own little seven-year-old suburban Topeka, Kansas, public school way, I took Miss Ryon quite literally. I didn’t even think there was another way to do this. To draw the garden scene from the eyes of a bug I had to BE the bug.

I drew the dirt I was crawling on, the giant leaves and stems springing up from the ground around me, the flowers way up overhead. And over to the right was a ginormous, humongous, very, very big sneakered foot.
Miss Ryon, coming across my desk as I worked the crayons, snatched it up! Oh shit! Only I didn’t say ‘oh shit’ at the time. Maybe I thought “Yikes! Was she going to tear it up? Throw it in the waste basket in disgust?” No. She did something much worse. She held it up in front of the class as an example! Everyone else was happily drawing a garden. A garden with bugs in it, for sure, but a garden from a kid’s point of view, not the bug’s. Miss Ryon used my picture to show the class the error of their ways. Miss Ryon directed the class to start over. I was proud and appalled at the same time, pretty sure everyone hated me at that moment. Fifteen minutes later Miss Ryon collected the do-over drawings and pinned them up on the bulletin board. (Do they still have bulletin boards?) and stepped back.
An Artist’s Stomach Ache
What I saw made my little artist’s stomach ache. Twenty or so renditions of a garden with lots of dirt, giant stems and leaves, flowers hovering above and a giant sneakered foot planted to the right. My first experience with plagiarism.
Miss Ryon moved on to multiplication or some such awfulness. Now as an adult, I imagine her heaving a sigh, wondering if she had only presented the idea differently more of her students might have unlocked their imaginations. She would never blame her students for messing up the assignment.
When Do People Stop Being Creative?
In the book Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear, Elizabeth Gilbert wrote about how a lot of people stop being creative because of an experience in childhood. Often it’s an adult, a parent or teacher, who shuts down the spark of creativity with an offhand remark that means nothing to the adult but leaves a lifelong mark on the child. That came many years later for me, a devastating moment in a college art class, but that’s another story.
Back in first grade, Miss Ryon was the opposite of thoughtless. She was a Good Teacher, one of my favorites. Ever. She was patient with the pack of us, always ready with genuine encouragement and praise. We grew confident under her dependable care, whether in creative projects, reading or multiplication tables.
One thing, among all the other things I’ve learned since starting my art practice, is that we humans are born creative. We all are. As we breathe, we create. We all learn through play, through imagining the fantastic. Like plants that grow in sunlight from which they produce material energy, we take in the sensational energy of the world and create material works. It doesn’t matter if it’s carved out of marble that lasts for centuries or a sand castle on a beach that will only be there until the next tide comes in. It is all good, creative work. Good teachers, like Miss Ryon, value and gently encourage our creative spirit. Thank you, Miss Ryon, and all good teachers everywhere.
About Dr Aletta

